Home Sport England Where are the English Top Order Replacements Coming From?
Where are the English Top Order Replacements Coming From?
1

Where are the English Top Order Replacements Coming From?

44
1

bairstow1

Today I’m going to try to have a look at the next group of batsmen in line for England. Obviously I’m no expert on English county cricket and will only be making guesses from statistical analysis and newspaper clippings as such.

First stop is good old StatsGuru.

When looking over the list of highest run scorers from Division 1, it is clear why Jonny Bairstow has been brought back into the fold. His record for this season is light years ahead of the rest. His 980 runs at 108.8 (S/R 78.27) with a top score of 219* is impressive by anyone’s books. Personally I put a lot of weight behind anyone that can score double hundreds; even on the flattest wickets it still takes concentration and resolve. Having never scored one myself, I know I used to start thinking I was going ok around 20, and was generally out by 25 because of it.

Behind Bairstow is Luke Wright, who we are familiar with from his time at the Melbourne stars in the Big Bash League. We have seen his power in the short form, but after 50 ODI matches for England, his average is an unimpressive 20.2.  From memory, I found him to be very on or off. His striking is as clean as anyone with the power to match, but test cricket demands consistency.

Scott Borthwick has scored 854 at 42.7 and was touted as a spinning option for England by Graeme Swann back in 2013. Despite his season average being seven runs higher than his career average, It wouldn’t be unfair to say that he probably isn’t viewed as a top order prospect to solve the current issues. He is only young, 25, and probably has his eye on a role similar to Moeen Ali.

James Hildreth seems to have the history of being looked at as a future prospect. He has played for the England’s U/15’s, U/19’s and as a member of the Performance Squad in 2007/08. It seems he never quite made the jump into what was a successful period for English Cricket.  To be honest, anyone looking to make the jump into test cricket for any country should be averaging well over 50 and closer to 60 in their local competition.

When expanding to division 2, Ashwell Prince tops the list as most runs with 1311 at 81.93 (S/R 67.85) with a high score of 261. Obviously he is unavailable being an international.

To me, highest averages are a better judge, as long as there have been enough innings on the board. I struggled to get a straight table sorted for highest averages. The only one that consistently came up was a minimum of 20 innings, which is fair enough. Except that eliminated the top eight averages.

Our mate KP is right up there at the moment with an average of a tick over 150. But im not even going to go there, that is an entire blog on its own.

We have already spoken about Bairstow (108.8) and Prince (81.93). Between them is Steven Davies (85.0) unfortunately he is a keeper/middle order batsmen.

Then comes Chris Read (58.9) the former England representative, who is past a recall.

Tom Westley is averaging 55.0 after 14 innings, which is a massive 20 runs higher than his career average. At 26 he is the right age for a long term prospect, and he has also had success at the top of the order. He has been spoken about for some time, but an injury a few years ago slowed progress and this year it seems it might be getting it together. The question is would you throw him against Johnson and co now? Or hold him off and give him a chance to dominate a season at county level and see if he can sustain, before throwing him to the lions?

The former South African representative, Alvero Peterson is next at 52.66 and Ryan ten Doeschate, the Dutch representative follows at 51.38.

There seems to be a concerning trend across all these statistics. Outside of Westley, the top performers are either middle order batsmen, internationals, or reaching the end of their careers.

This must be ringing alarm bells at the ECB.

It wasn’t so long ago that we faced a similar problem in Australia. A few retired greats and no real succession plan, led to a period of frustration for Aussie fans and selectors alike. It’s really only in the last 18-24 months that stocks have started to fill up.

I think I remember hearing talk, or reading articles, a few years ago about starting to move Australian pitches towards more batsmen friendly so we could develop the mental toughness of batting for long periods and bowling long spells to prepare for test cricket better.

I’m not sure how much change to pitch preparation there was, if there was even such a discussion, but I think the drop in wickets have definitely taken away some of the distinct personalities from our pitches. In a purists sense it does my head in, but sport is a business and sharing these amazing facilities goes hand in hand, so what will be, will be.

All teams ebb and flow in their success. Some can sustain at the top longer than others, but all dynasties fall. I’m certainly not saying that England had a dynasty, but success papers over problems in the local system. We found it here in Australia and we paid for it on the international scene for a few years. England may be staring down the barrel of such a period, which is bittersweet.

International cricket needs a strong English side. Unfortunately they are integral to the sport on a global marketing scale. Let’s hope things turn around quickly, but no too quick….

 

 

Division 1

Most runs
Player Mat Inns NO Runs HS Ave BF SR 100 50 0 4s 6s
JM Bairstow 7 12 3 980 219* 108.88 1252 78.27 5 4 1 126 15
(Yorkshire)
LJ Wright 11 21 1 897 110 44.85 1362 65.85 1 8 1 134 11
(Sussex)
SG Borthwick 11 22 2 854 103 42.70 1373 62.19 1 7 1 122 2
(Durham)
JC Hildreth 11 20 0 853 187 42.65 1319 64.67 1 5 1 113 9
(Somerset)
MD Stoneman 11 22 0 827 131 37.59 1258 65.73 3 3 2 108 7
(Durham)
MW Machan 9 17 0 774 192 45.52 949 81.55 3 2 2 100 7
(Sussex)
NRD Compton 11 21 2 769 117 40.47 1604 47.94 1 5 2 94 1
(Middlesex)
JA Leaning 10 16 2 756 123 54.00 1468 51.49 3 2 0 98 4
(Yorkshire)
BRM Taylor 11 20 0 749 152 37.45 1299 57.65 3 2 2 98 1
(Nottinghamshire)
ME Trescothick 11 22 0 733 140 33.31 1309 55.99 1 6 4 119 3
(Somerset)

 

Division 2

Most runs
Player Mat Inns NO Runs HS Ave BF SR 100 50 0 4s 6s
AG Prince 12 17 1 1311 261 81.93 1932 67.85 5 4 0 163 12
(Lancashire)
SA Northeast 11 21 2 840 88* 44.21 1397 60.12 0 6 1 109 3
(Kent)
AN Petersen 11 16 1 790 286 52.66 1288 61.33 3 1 1 99 2
(Lancashire)
NLJ Browne 11 20 0 772 143 38.60 1511 51.09 3 3 0 117 1
(Essex)
AJ Robson 11 22 0 714 120 32.45 1307 54.62 1 5 1 106 2
(Leicestershire)
GG Wagg 11 16 0 696 200 43.50 952 73.10 1 3 1 82 27
(Glamorgan)
RI Keogh 11 21 2 689 163* 36.26 1205 57.17 2 2 1 94 2
(Northamptonshire)
JL Denly 11 21 2 686 117* 36.10 1368 50.14 1 5 2 95 7
(Kent)
SM Davies 7 11 3 680 200* 85.00 996 68.27 2 2 1 74 5
(Surrey)
JA Rudolph 11 20 2 674 111 37.44 1407 47.90 1 4 0 92 0
(Glamorgan)

 

(44)

Comments

comments

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT

SO YOU WANT FREE MERCH!?

The deal is simple. Fill out the form on the right hand side of the page. If your name gets drawn, we will send you an email and strike a deal on what merch you want. It can be anything from a Test, ODI or T20 shirt, perhaps a training polo and hat, or maybe just a stubby cooler... All from the team of your choice.

That’s right, we will scroll through their website to find what they have available and get something to your liking. The best thing is, once you have signed up you are in the draw every month. The only catch is, you can’t win two months in a row, and we get to send you an email to update you on the latest each week.

Our promise to you is that we will not give your details to anyone without your consent. Sound good? Put your details down and keep an eye on your emails.

Benny.
Director, Cricket Fans United.

Close this popup

Sign Up for Free Bats and Merchandise. Drawn Every Month This Summer.

Good Luck Cricket Fans!

SO YOU WANT FREE MERCH!?

The deal is simple. Fill out the form on the right hand side of the page. If your name gets drawn, we will send you an email and strike a deal on what merch you want. It can be anything from a Test, ODI or T20 shirt, perhaps a training polo and hat, or maybe just a stubby cooler... All from the team of your choice.

That’s right, we will scroll through their website to find what they have available and get something to your liking. The best thing is, once you have signed up you are in the draw every month. The only catch is, you can’t win two months in a row, and we get to send you an email to update you on the latest each week.

Our promise to you is that we will not give your details to anyone without your consent. Sound good? Put your details down and keep an eye on your emails.

Benny.
Director, Cricket Fans United.

Close this popup

Sign Up for Free Bats and Merchandise. Drawn Every Month This Summer.

Good Luck Cricket Fans!

SO YOU WANT FREE MERCH!?

The deal is simple. Fill out the form on the right hand side of the page. If your name gets drawn, we will send you an email and strike a deal on what merch you want. It can be anything from a Test, ODI or T20 shirt, perhaps a training polo and hat, or maybe just a stubby cooler... All from the team of your choice.

That’s right, we will scroll through their website to find what they have available and get something to your liking. The best thing is, once you have signed up you are in the draw every month. The only catch is, you can’t win two months in a row, and we get to send you an email to update you on the latest each week.

Our promise to you is that we will not give your details to anyone without your consent. Sound good? Put your details down and keep an eye on your emails.

Benny.
Director, Cricket Fans United.

Close this popup

Sign Up for Free Bats and Merchandise. Drawn Every Month This Summer.

Good Luck Cricket Fans!